The Ocean Avenue Association's governing board elected new members in a tie vote at its Nov. 9 meeting, an action in apparent conflict with state law.
The nonprofit organization charged by City Hall with cleaning and maintaining Ingleside and Lakeside Villageโs Ocean Avenue has a bigger budget, better compensated staff and more grant funding for events, yet its volunteer board of directors continues to struggle with infighting instead of adding more street cleaners to the avenue. The discord was on full display with the boardโs deliberation over adding five new members.
Tensions began when Director Cindy Huynh, co-owner of Ocean Hair Design, asked for an update on Copy Edge co-owner Jenny Ginโs application to join the board.
President Kath Tsakalakis said the governance and nominating committee declined to advance Ginโs application over a conflict of interest.
Director Gavin Chak asked if Gin was made aware of the status of her application. Tsakalakis said she had not followed up with Gin and that Gin did not reach out either.
Treasurer Tiffany Zhang and Director Wei Sei Lei asked how voting for the new members would work and how the process of selecting board nominees is conducted.
โThe governance and nominating committee looked in June at the matrix of what skills are we looking to fill, what profiles of people, what skills are we missing, finance skills and so on,โ Tsakalakis said. โWe looked at the matrix and we actively recruited five people that we feel meet the balance of the neighborhood, different types of businesses, etc.โ
Several directors, including Korean Martial Arts Center instructor Larry Dorsey, asked if there was a way to include Gin in board activities, to which Tsakalakis said one option was to ask her to join one of the associationโs four committees, which are open to the public to join and she would speak to her following the meeting.
Tsakalakis added there will be opportunities for Gin to join the board as members are termed out. said. She cited that City College of San Francisco Associate Vice Chancellor of Facilities and Planning Alberto Vasquezโs second term will end on Aug. 16, 2027.
When the question of electing new directors came up, Chak said he didnโt believe it was the best time, noting how the board was dysfunctional and had issues to address.
At its August board meeting, it was revealed that the San Francisco Office of Economic & Workforce Development, which oversees the association, had issued a notice letter requiring that it hold a meeting on governance after receiving numerous reports of members ignoring the Brown Act, a state open meeting law. During the same meeting, Zhang, along with her attorney Michael G. Zatkin, alleged that she had been stripped of her title without following the associationโs handbook and bylaws. Moreover, The Ingleside Light found that the association did not comply with open meetings law when it did not provide all necessary meeting documents to the public.
Moreover, the association held an emergency meeting of its finance and audit committee the Friday before, where Zhang took issue with the association hiring a new bookkeeper without informing her. Tsakalakis said that since itโs a staffing decision, it is outside of their purview as board members. Megan Catmull, the associationโs executive director, shared that she hired a family friend to work on the organizationโs events, which will be paid for by a new city grant.
Tie-Vote Election
โRight now, we have a lot of problems,โ Chak said. โThe procedure, the responsibility of everyone, and the shape of the power of each member. What I think is the confusion right now, during the past meetings, we had problems with that, so I think we have to focus on clearing all the mess that we have.โ
Tsakalakis countered that adding more directors with different skill sets would help address several ongoing issues, such as forming a quorum. Jackie Hazelwood, the Community Benefit District Program Director for San Franciscoโs Office of Economic and Workforce Development, was in the audience.
The nominees were San Francisco Department of Public Worksโ Chief Financial Officer Bruce Robertson, The Fatherโs House owner and lead pastor Robyn Bittle, Ambrosia Bakeryโs Keith Truong and Ocean Avenue Clearpoint Real Estateโs Julien Goavec. Doug Kilroy, the trustee and audit chair for Gateway Public Schools, was also considered but was not present at the meeting.
โThis is a perfect example where it looks like four of us want to bring in new board members and new skills, and four people, for whatever reason, have decided before coming to this meeting that you don't want this,โ Tsakalakis said.

Chak said he wanted a clarification on the positions of power for each member and on how procedures were conducted, noting that it was still unclear that they werenโt in the position to add new board members and how they should have a special meeting to discuss further.
Tsakalakis said that the board would be stuck at 50-50 for the vote and began to thank the nominees for their time before Vasquez stated that they would still have to do an official vote.
Tsakalakis moved to elect the five new board members. Dorsey seconded. Tsakalakis, Dorsey, Vasquez and Lick Wilmerding High Schoolโs Ravi Lau voted yes, and Chak, Huynh, Zhang and Wei Sei Lei voted no.
Tsakalakis told The Ingleside Light that the associationโs bylaws define a majority vote as 50% of the quorum of directors in attendance at the meeting, resulting in the motion to elect the members passing.
However, the bylaws section Tsakalakis cited has a clause stating โunless these Bylaws or applicable law provides differently.โ The association is subject to the California Corporations Code. The code's section 7211(a)(8)) states, โThe articles or bylaws may not provide that a lesser vote than a majority of the directors present at a meeting is the act of the board.โ
The board would not be able to elect new members, in this instance, without at least five affirmative votes. The bylaws clause was not discussed at the meeting.
The meeting continued with the board tabling an item for electing officers and then moved into closed session for confidential discussion. Tsakalakis told The Ingleside Light that no reportable actions were taken during closed session.
The boardโs next meeting is scheduled for February 2027.